This all began with a question at Shakespeare's Sister's website:
If you were an actor, whose career would you most want to have?
My answer was John Cusack - the man has a varied and quirky resume that I particularly appreciate.
And one of the movies I most appreciate his work in is Eight Men Out, in my humble opinion one of the best movies ever made about baseball. It truly is, although comparing it with other supposed great baseball movies is damning with faint praise. (See this list for the possibilities)
And I started wondering - with all the history that has involved baseball, and with all the money that, in theory, could be available to make movies about that baseball history, and with all the fans and SABRmatricians with cash to spend on such a product, why doesn't Major League Baseball finance a baseball movie at least once a decade? Wouldn't it benefit the sport, both short- and long-term? There are so many interesting stories out there to be told, and I am NOT suggesting individual biographies, which can and are done on television. The story of baseball during World War II, the evolution of the inclusion of Central American players, the battle between baseball and church over Sunday games, the free-agency movement, etc... there are SO MANY options. So why isn't it part of the MLB program by now?
I recognize that there's a risk that such movies can turn into propaganda, because baseball owners aren't the smartest people in the world, and yet can be some of the most stubborn, and particularly in stories such as the reserve-clause, there could be a severe risk of having a once-in-ten-years effort completely backfire on them. The goal would be to generate a greater appreciation for the sport, and to that end, benefit organized baseball.
And here's how you start such an effort - send out a letter to every baseball beat writer, major league general manager and field manager in the country, and ask them this simple question:
What is the most interesting baseball story that's never been told in movies?
Think you'll find at least one great movie in that process? I think you'll find dozens.


